Sea Bright Pizza Restaurant

Reviews

• Kira S.

  star star star star star 1 July 2026

  Best pizza, best service, best place in sea bright! Yum yum. I've moved here from Bergen county and my standards for pizza are exceptional. Eat where the locals eat! Eat here!

• J T.

  star star star star star 22 June 2026

  This little hidden gem has some of the best pizza around. They're cash only, but have an ATM inside. Their Grandma Pizza is life altering. It's the prefect blend of garlic, tomato chunks, and perfectly melted/toasty cheese. I highly recommend it to all. Closed on Mondays, but every other day of the week they're churning out masterful pizza.

• John S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 17 June 2026

  Ordered 3 Pies for pickup thursday evening 1 plain, 1 pepperoni, 1 chicken parm,,, guy who answered the phone told me 30 minutes for the food to be done,, I arrive to the spot 45 minutes later,, upon entering the employee tells me that they are still working on my order and it will be another 10-15 minutes.. I said Okay! sat down waited another 20 minutes got up and asked the young man where my food was... he tells me that unfortunatly they sent my food out on delivery and are waiting for it to return to the shop... thats it the last straw after waiting over an hour for food the manager rudly starts yelling and screaming at me. I would give this place a negative 5 stars if possible.. not only have they lost a great customer but they also need to work on their business skills.  .... Never Again!

• Jena M.

  star star star star star_border 12 June 2026

  ~ Cash only
  ~ Outdoor seating
  ~ They have espresso!
  
  Came here yesterday with my boyfriend and friends. Yum! Pizza is simple and delicious. Unsure of the reviews about the cheese being too thick, ours was thin and appetizing. We probably could have eaten two pies easily! Staff was friendly and quick. My friends were behind us and another gentleman came to their assistance. Decor is beautiful! We loved the ceilings :) A little more pricey than regular pizza spots up north, but hey, you're down the shore!

• Jess S.

  star star star star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  What a difficult review. The pizza is outstanding but the service is most definitely not. We waited for a LONG time for our pie yesterday despite having ordered as a walk in while the restaurant was empty. I acknowledge the takeout orders and call ins, however it seemed we'd been forgotten. Upon asking how much longer, the man up front said it was being taken out of the oven which was not the case as the pizza he took out was given to another walk in (probably phone order). I assume he was not lying, just confused. But, waiting almost 40 minutes for a pie in an empty place is absurd. If they improve their service, I would consider returning often during the summer. Also, a bit overpriced, but understandable (almost) given the location.